- 5 stars: 745 (83%)
- 4 stars: 84 (9%)
- 3 stars: 66 (7%)
- 2 stars: 0 (0%)
- 1 star: 0 (0%)
Great pencil, sharp applies well without any irritation and doesnt smudge.
Thank you so much for your lovely review.
We’re delighted to hear you’re enjoying the Eye Pencil and that it applies smoothly without irritation or smudging. It’s great to know it’s performing so well for you, especially around the delicate eye area.
Thanks again for taking the time to share your experience — we really appreciate your support.
Great coverage and color
The pencil is very narrow compared to the former one and is very hard
The sample mascara was way better than the two I purchased
The best eye pencil I have ever used.
The best eye pencil on the market. Lasts long and lasts long time while using
This product is perfect for me. It soft, but not to soft and can be smudged out with a small brush.
The eye shadow stick color is okay. It’s more beige versus rise is color. Easy to apply
Perfect color taupe. Like knowing that l am applying clean products to my eyes!
Everything was great
Does exactly what I want - I can go from subtle to more dramatic with ease.
I like this... color is excellent for me- black/gray.
Goes on smoothly, colors are perfect!
This is my go to eye pencil. I love the way it goes on and it is easy to blend. Stay on all day. Feels good to know that I am using quality products on such a delicate area of the face.
This goes on smoothly and has excellent staying power! I have tried it solo and also layered with a shadow. Either way, it is a great go to. I look forward to seeing some special color offerings in greens or even purples, but as a basic/every day, the taupe is an amazing no-makeup makeup color.
Goes on smoothly. This is the only makeup I don’t have allergy reactions to. I love it.
Smooth application, lasting color.
Really appreciate Jane Iredale clean products. No eye irritation and staying power.
Eyeliners are smooth to apply. If a few more colors were offered, I wouldn't have to shop elsewhere for additional colors.
My salon hair stylist introduced me to your product line, and I have found the quality, texture, and ease of applying this pencil the finest I have ever used.
Nice pencil but I wish it was a bit softer to allow for easier blending. Great color though. I wish it had an automatic sharpener.
Great eye pencil! Goes on smoothly, lasts long, does not bother my very sensitive eyes. I do wish more colors were available!
Excellent eyeliner for contact lens users! No irritation, lasts, easy to apply and easy to remove. LOVE the black/brown color!
Creamy texture and nice warm tone - on the lighter brown side.
good on eye brows not as eye liner. Brown colored handle housing one worked better. New white housing don’t go on smoothly and don’t stay on but couple hours.
Jane Iredale company very graciously. refunded my money
Great Pencil. Doesn't smudge!
Nice neutral color. Does not wear as long as I would like.
This pencil goes on smoothly. And stays in place!
Tremendous products!!
A product that works!
Glides on so smooth! Natural color looks so good!
I love actual pencils that you can sharpen and this does not disappoint!
Best eyebrow pencil ever and eyeliner pervert blonde color
Perfect for blue eyes
Nice color but it doesn’t stay on all day especially when it is hot outside.
Hi
When will you have the black/brown eye pencil back in stock?
Hi Diane! Thank you for sending us your question! We are happy to let you know that the black/brown eye pencil is now back in stock ❤️
