- 5 stars: 166 (81%)
- 4 stars: 21 (10%)
- 3 stars: 18 (9%)
- 2 stars: 0 (0%)
- 1 star: 0 (0%)
Nice Thin line, goes on smooth, looks really clean.
I’ve used this product for years, even when they had multiple colors. It’s always stayed on, was quick to try and easy to fix! It does seem like it’s been watered down more than the past purchases but it’s still a great product.
I love this liquid eyeliner. I use it almost daily. In my opinion, the other options just don’t measure up! I loved the dark brown shade, too, and was disappointed when it was discontinued
Love this eyeliner. Stays in place all day with no smudging.
This is simply the best eyeliner. The packaging, the ingredients, the applicator —nothing is wrong.
Loved it . Flawless and best natural eyeliner I ever used.
I love this eyeliner! Any other manufacturers give an allergic reaction! I love Jane Iredale!
Really love this, always will be a black eyeliner girl. Application wand is a little too tiny and unsupportive but otherwise its perfect.
It's the only eyeliner I can use without getting dermatitis
Would like brown again as I am fair.
I have been searching for a clean eyeliner that actually stays put. I love the thin line and this doesn't smudge at all!!!
Best eyeliner stayed on all day and didn’t make my eye irritated
The eyeliner is a nice dark color and stays in place all day. However, I feel the brush is alittle too thin. It is too thin to apply one nice line across the lid and it is challenging to make the line thicker by going over it again. It ends up looking messy.
Easy to apply for a subtle or more bold look. Gentle on sensitive eyes.
The only eyeliner I use!
Love the eyeliner and I have been using it for years. Plus it stays on all day and the bottle last a very long time.
Great eyeliner, it is hard to find a good liquid,clean, cruelty free, and vegan eyeliner. Goes on easily with a nice applicator.
Hard to put on
I love the fact that it makes a very thin line, I just wish it came in different colors such as brown, smoke and or dark blue..
I’m very happy with the fine brush and pigment. I wish you offered this liner and more colors such as light platinum brown.
This is a great product. I like liquid liner because it is easier to control and define. Jane Iredale products are clean, pure! Great site to get these products. Fast delivery!
This is a great product. I like liquid liner because it is easier to control and define. Jane Iredale products are clean, pure! Great site to get these products. Fast delivery!
It’s good, has good & safe ingredients..just lacks the intensity of other brands I have used. Without the intensity of the black liner it doesn’t last as long.
I have bought and returned several eyeliners but the Jane Iredale was the perfect one! The color is jet black and the application creates a precise cat eye. Or if I want a more relaxed look I can paint a simple line.
I have super sensitive skin but the formula is free of chemicals and does not cause any reactions.
I have been using Jane iredale exclusively for over 20 years. It’s been the best for my acne prone skin. I love that it’s not full of chemicals and the colors make for a more natural look which I’m after. I recommend it to everyone! I’m so happy my dermatologist suggested it to me years ago!
I have been using Jane iredale exclusively for over 20 years. It’s been the best for my acne prone skin. I love that it’s not full of chemicals and the colors make for a more natural look which I’m after. I recommend it to everyone! I’m so happy my dermatologist suggested it to me years ago!
I really like this eyeliner - I love that there aren't toxic ingredients. The only reason I gave it 4 stars is because for some reason there are times that it creates a slight burning sensation on my eyelid (but not always). I'm sure it's due to my sensitive skin, but I haven't had other eyeliners do this in the past. Obviously it's not too terrible, as I'm on my second tube.
I really like this eyeliner - I love that there aren't toxic ingredients. The only reason I gave it 4 stars is because for some reason there are times that it creates a slight burning sensation on my eyelid (but not always). I'm sure it's due to my sensitive skin, but I haven't had other eyeliners do this in the past. Obviously it's not too terrible, as I'm on my second tube.
Love the product.
Clean and fine line easy to control
Love the product.
Clean and fine line easy to control
I've used this in the past and I loved it. This reorder seems watery. I have to put on several coats to be a solid black without streaks. With every coat, you risk the chance of smudging .
I love the eyeliner! It stays on and doesn't smudge. Makes a nice thin line.
I love the eyeliner! It stays on and doesn't smudge. Makes a nice thin line.
Glides easily & no smudges
Glides easily & no smudges
